The UK Diver’s Guide to Streamlining: Accessories & Hardware

Pros & Cons: Retractors vs. Bolt Snaps

In the showroom, a retractor feels like magic: pull it out, let it go, and it zips back into place. But in the North Sea, at 30 meters on a rusting hulk, that convenience often turns into a liability.

The debate is effectively a choice between ease of access (Retractors) and security/streamlining (Bolt Snaps). Here is the breakdown for the cold-water diver.

---

1. The Retractor: The “False Friend”

Retractors are spring-loaded cable reels that auto-retract gear. They are standard issue in rental kits and tropical diving, but they struggle in the UK environment.

The Pros:

• Zero Learning Curve: Intuitive. Grab the gauge, look at it, let go.
• Immediate “Tidiness”: Keeps hoses from dragging on the floor (initially).

The Cons:

• The “Rust Roulette”: Most retractors rely on an internal coil spring. Even “marine grade” plastic housings eventually leak. Once saltwater hits that cheap internal spring, it rusts, jams, and snaps—usually when you are relying on it.
• Entanglement Hazard: A retractor creates a thin, high-tension line of Spectra or nylon. On a wreck, if you snag that line on a piece of metal, you are tethered to the ship. Because it is under tension, you can’t easily create slack to unhook it.
• The “Droop”: Heavy consoles pull the retractor cable out partially, leaving gear dangling 10–20cm below you—perfect for dragging through silt or smashing into coral/wreckage.

Verdict: Avoid for critical gear. Acceptable only for very light accessories (like a compass slate) in open water, but generally discouraged for UK diving.

---

2. The Bolt Snap (Piston Snap): The “North Sea Standard”

A solid stainless steel piston snap tied to the gear with caveline.

The Pros:

• Fail-Safe: If the internal spring breaks (rare in 316 stainless), the gate usually stays closed. You don’t lose the gear; you just have to manually fiddle it open later.
• Streamlined: It forces gear to sit flush against your D-rings. No dangling, no drag.
• Standardization: Once you learn to clip your SPG to your left hip, you can find it in zero visibility by feeling your way down the D-ring.

The Cons:

• The Dexterity Barrier: Operating the small piston slide with 5mm neoprene gloves or dry gloves requires practice.
• Rigging Required: You cannot just buy it and dive. You must cut off the plastic/rubber boot on your gauge and tie the snap on correctly with line (metal-to-metal connections wear through; metal-to-line does not).

Verdict: Essential for all life-support and expensive gear (SPG, regulators, cameras, lights).

---

Comparison Table: UK Survivability

Feature	Retractor	Bolt Snap (316 Stainless)
Durability	Low: Internal springs rust; plastic casings crack in cold.	High: Virtually indestructible.
Failure Mode	Catastrophic: Line snaps, gear falls to the abyss.	Benign: Spring fails, clip stays closed.
Snag Hazard	High: Creates a thin line trap.	Low: Closed system, smooth profile.
Glove Use	Medium: Easy to pull, hard to lock.	Hard (initially): Requires muscle memory.
Cost	£20 – £40 (recurring replacement).	£8 – £12 (Buy once).

---

What To Use Where: The Rigging Guide

If you are transitioning from “holiday diver” to “UK diver,” here is the standard configuration map:

1. The SPG (Pressure Gauge)

• Verdict: Bolt Snap (Medium/Large).
• Why: A retractor here allows the gauge to drag or snag. A bolt snap clipped to the Left Hip D-Ring keeps the gauge tucked tight against your waist strap. You unclip to read, then reclip.

2. Backup/Primary Lights

• Verdict: Bolt Snap (Double-Ender or Fixed).
• Why: If you drop a torch on a retractor, it dangles and blinds your buddy (or you). If you drop a bolted torch, it hangs securely on the D-ring.
• Rigging: Clip the head of the torch to the Right Shoulder D-Ring so it tucks into the shoulder strap.

3. GoPro / Compact Camera

• Verdict: Bolt Snap + Coiled Lanyard (with Buckle).
• Why: This is the one exception where a pure bolt snap is risky (dropping the camera when unclipping).
• The Setup: Use a bolt snap to secure the camera to your Chest D-Ring when not in use. When filming, unclip the bolt snap, but keep a heavy-duty coiled lanyard attached to your wrist or harness as a “fail-safe.” Never use a retractor for a camera; the tension makes steady filming impossible.

4. Wetnotes / Slates

• Verdict: Double-Ender Bolt Snap.
• Why: Store these in your thigh pocket. The double-ender connects the slate to the bungee loop inside the pocket. You pull it out, use it, and stuff it back in. No dangling.

---

💡 Pro Tip: The “Big Eye” Solution

The biggest reason divers hate bolt snaps is that they buy the wrong size.

• Standard Size: Fine for bare hands in the Red Sea.
• UK Size: You need “Big Eye” or “Large swivel” snaps.
• Why: The larger swivel loop allows the snap to rotate freely even when gloved fingers are jammed against it, and the trigger is usually extended for easier purchase with thick neoprene.